The New March of Folly: From Troy to Nuclear Brink

Here is a polished, condensed essay version of our entire discussion, formatted with **H1, H2, and H3 tags** for WordPress and Substack. You can copy and paste this directly into your editor.

—

# The New March of Folly: From Troy to Nuclear Brink

Table of Contents

## How Western Hubris is Repeating History’s Deadliest Mistakes

—

### Introduction: Tuchman’s Framework and the Modern Crisis

In her seminal work, *The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam*, the historian Barbara W. Tuchman defined political folly as the pursuit of policies contrary to a state’s own self-interest—even when feasible alternatives existed and the policy was recognized as counter-productive in its own time. She identified a recurring pattern in human governance: the stubborn refusal of ruling elites to abandon failed strategies, driven by what she called “wooden-headedness”—the assessment of a situation according to fixed preconceptions while stubbornly rejecting contrary evidence.

Tuchman’s case studies—the Trojan Horse, the Renaissance Popes, Britain’s loss of the American colonies, and America’s Vietnam War—all share a tragic commonality. In each instance, a powerful state or institution marched confidently toward disaster, ignoring clear warnings, rejecting viable alternatives, and clinging to delusions of invincibility until reality shattered them.

**The disturbing truth is that this pattern has not ended. It has merely accelerated.**

Today, we find ourselves in the midst of a new March of Folly—one that encompasses the Cold War, the current conflict in Ukraine, and the decades-long confrontation with Iran. The stakes are now existential. As Daniel Ellsberg warned in his final years, the same delusional mindset that drove the Vietnam War now governs nuclear policy, bringing humanity perilously close to annihilation.

—

### Historical Follies: The Bloody Precedents

#### World War I: A Family Feud That Killed Millions

If Tuchman’s case studies were tragic, the World Wars were catastrophic beyond measure. Yet both fit her framework with devastating precision.

World War I was triggered by the assassination of a single archduke—a crisis that *could* have been localized through diplomacy. Austria-Hungary could have accepted Serbia’s near-complete capitulation. Russia could have restrained its mobilization. Germany could have called off the invasion of Belgium. Instead, the Great Powers marched blindly into a war that destroyed four empires, permanently diminished European global hegemony, and sowed the seeds for an even more catastrophic conflict.

**The “wooden-headedness” was rooted in aristocratic pride and rigid military timetables.** The crowned heads of Europe—George V of Britain, Wilhelm II of Germany, and Nicholas II of Russia—were first cousins, all grandchildren of Queen Victoria. They wrote to each other in affectionate, familial terms even as their generals mobilized millions to kill one another. They believed they could conduct a “limited” war. They were tragically wrong.

#### World War II: Appeasement and the Hitler Miscalculation

The folly of World War II was a compounding of the first. After the horrors of 1914-1918, the Western Allies pursued a policy of appeasement toward Hitler with the explicit, cynical goal of directing German aggression *eastward* against the Soviet Union.

**They sacrificed Czechoslovakia at Munich in 1938, believing they could manipulate a monster.**

The result was the exact opposite. Hitler signed a non-aggression pact with Stalin in 1939, invaded Poland, and then turned west to crush France and bomb Britain. The policy designed to destroy Communism instead empowered it, as the Red Army ultimately occupied half of Europe. Over fifty million people died.

—

### The Cold War and Its Aftermath: Unipolar Hubris

#### The 1953 Iranian Coup: The Original Sin

The current confrontation with Iran has its roots in the CIA-orchestrated coup of 1953, which overthrew the democratically elected Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh. Driven by Cold War geopolitics and oil interests, the United States and Britain viewed Iran through a lens of imperial presumption.

**The result was not a stable ally, but decades of deep-seated anti-Americanism.**

This action paved the way for the 1979 Iranian Revolution and created an animosity that has defined U.S.-Iran relations ever since. Instead of securing influence, the West created an implacable adversary—a textbook example of a policy that was counterproductive from its inception.

#### The 2014 Ukrainian Coup and NATO Expansion

Similarly, the current war in Ukraine can be traced to the 2014 coup that ousted Ukraine’s democratically elected president—an event widely seen in Russia as a CIA-backed operation. This was followed by the steady expansion of NATO eastward, despite warnings from realists like George F. Kennan, who called it a “most fateful error.”

**The West’s delusion was that it could goad Russia into a war it could win.**

Instead, Russia was provoked into a conflict that has devastated Ukraine, disrupted global energy and food supplies, and pushed Moscow into a closer alliance with Beijing. The result is a more dangerous, more unstable world—the precise opposite of the West’s stated goals.

—

### The Root Delusion: The “Garden” Mentality

#### 500 Years of Imperial Presumption

At the heart of these follies lies a single, persistent delusion: the belief that after 500 years of Western imperialism, the “Garden”—as French diplomat Jean Borel put it—should have perpetual jurisdiction and hegemony over the vast majority of the planet.

**This “wooden-headedness” manifests as an assumption of inevitable victory.**

The West believed it could defeat Iran since the Shah was overthrown in 1979. It believed it could goad Russia into a war and win in 2014. It believed that “maximum pressure” would bring both adversaries to their knees. In each case, the policy has failed, yet the commitment to it persists—even as Western economies suffer and more people die needlessly.

This is the essence of Tuchman’s folly: the rejection of reason in favor of fixed preconceptions. The West cannot conceive of a multipolar world where Russia and Iran have legitimate spheres of influence. It cannot accept that the post-Cold War unipolar moment was a historical anomaly, not a permanent state. Instead of adapting to reality, it clings to the delusion that its power is still absolute.

—

### The Nuclear Dimension: Ellsberg’s Warning

#### When Folly Becomes Existential

Daniel Ellsberg, who exposed the Pentagon Papers, spent his later years warning that the same mentality that drove Vietnam now governs nuclear policy. He revealed that U.S. nuclear war plans, even during the Vietnam era, envisioned the deliberate killing of hundreds of millions of civilians—not as a response to an attack, but as a *first strike* option.

**The “wooden-headedness” is the belief that nuclear war is “winnable.”**

Ellsberg argued that the U.S. has come terrifyingly close to nuclear war multiple times due to accidents, miscalculations, and the sheer automaticity of command structures. The same secretive, hubristic mindset that led to Vietnam now controls the launch codes.

In the context of Ukraine and Iran, this is not a distant threat. The West has repeatedly escalated—supplying longer-range missiles, assassinating generals, and threatening military strikes. Each escalation is justified as “deterrence,” but from the adversary’s perspective, it looks like an existential threat that justifies its own escalation.

**The result is a spiral with no logical endpoint except catastrophe.**

—

### The Inevitability of a Major Conflagration

#### The Uncomfortable Conclusion

Tuchman’s framework forces us to ask: *Does a march of folly ever end peacefully, or only in catastrophic collapse?*

– World War I ended in exhaustion and the collapse of empires.
– World War II ended in the utter destruction of Germany and Japan.
– Vietnam ended in humiliating withdrawal.
– The Cold War’s end created a unipolar moment that the West could not sustain.

If this pattern holds, the current policy toward Ukraine and Iran will not be abandoned through wisdom or introspection. It will only yield when the costs become unbearable—and with nuclear weapons in the equation, “unbearable” could mean the end of civilization itself.

**The West’s arrogant mindset cannot change from within.**

It must be *broken* by external reality. The question is whether that reality will arrive as a conventional defeat or as a nuclear conflagration. As Ellsberg warned, the latter is all too possible—and perhaps even probable, given the current trajectory.

—

### A Path Forward? The Lantern on the Stern

#### Hindsight as a Tool, Not a Guarantee

Tuchman ends her book with the metaphor of a “lantern on the stern”—hindsight illuminates where we have been, but rarely shows where we are going. The West has ample historical evidence that confrontation with Russia and Iran has repeatedly failed to achieve its stated goals. Yet it persists.

**The countervailing force must come from the public, not the ruling class.**

If there is any hope, it lies in the awakening of Western publics to the costs and futility of endless confrontation. It lies in the election of leaders willing to pursue genuine diplomacy and compromise. It lies in the recognition that a multipolar world is not a threat to the West, but a reality that must be managed, not reversed.

—

### Conclusion: The March Continues

The “March of Folly” is not a historical curiosity—it is a living process that is accelerating toward a potentially terminal conclusion. From the assassination of a duke in Sarajevo to the battlefields of Ukraine, from the oil fields of Iran to the nuclear command centers of the Cold War, the pattern repeats: hubris, delusion, and the refusal to accept reality until it is too late.

**The West believes it is the master of history. In truth, it is a prisoner of its own arrogance.**

Whether humanity will break free of this prison before it becomes a tomb is the great unknown of our age. Tuchman could only diagnose the disease. The cure—if it exists—lies not in the halls of power, but in the willingness of ordinary people to see through the delusions of their rulers and demand a different path.

**History will judge whether we had the wisdom to stop marching.**

—

*This essay was inspired by Barbara W. Tuchman’s “The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam” and the writings of Daniel Ellsberg, applied to contemporary geopolitics.*

—

### Formatting Notes for WordPress and Substack:

– **H1** is used for the main title and the final conclusion heading.
– **H2** is used for the major section headings (e.g., “Historical Follies,” “The Nuclear Dimension”).
– **H3** is used for sub-sections (e.g., “World War I,” “The 1953 Iranian Coup”).
– **Bold text** is used for key thesis statements and impactful quotes to aid scanning.
– The essay is structured with clear, short paragraphs suitable for online reading.

You can copy this directly into your WordPress or Substack editor. If the platform uses a visual editor, you may need to manually apply the heading styles using the toolbar.